The Nepal government
should act immediately to fix crucial flaws in the Truth and
Reconciliation Commission (TRC) Act, particularly those highlighted in a
new United Nations evaluation, Amnesty International, Human Rights
Watch, and the International Commission of Jurists said today.
The
assessment, in a technical note from the UN Office of the High
Commissioner on Human rights to the Nepal government, pointed out that
the TRC Act does not conform to Nepal’s international legal obligations,
including in that it allows for amnesty for crimes committed under
international law. Five experts for the UN Human Rights Council have
also voiced similar serious concerns over the TRC Act, passed by Nepal’s
Constituent Assembly in April 2014.
“The UN’s findings
are consistent with what human rights groups have been saying all along –
Nepal’s TRC Act is fundamentally flawed and could leave thousands of
victims of conflict-related violations without access to the justice
they deserve,” said Richard Bennett, Asia director at Amnesty
International. “The act allows the commission to recommend amnesties for
crimes under international law, including war crimes, which flies in
the face of Nepal’s obligations under international law.”
Nepal’s
Supreme Court in January rejected an earlier version of the TRC Act –
the 2013 Truth and Reconciliation Ordinance, which contained many of the
same flawed provisions. The court ruled that any mechanism for
transitional justice must conform to international legal standards, lead
to accountability for serious human rights violations, and guarantee
victims their right to remedy and reparation.
Nepal’s
Constituent Assembly defied the Supreme Court ruling, and passed the TRC
Act. It became law on May 11, 2014. The act is only a slightly modified
version of the 2013 TRC Ordinance and fails to address the Supreme
Court’s concerns. The Supreme Court is set to rule on a petition
challenging the new act in July 2014.
In its briefing
paper issued in May, Justice Denied: the 2014 Commission on
Investigation of Disappeared Persons, Truth and Reconciliation Act, the
ICJ highlighted the flaws of the new TRC Act and called on the
government to take active steps to implement the Supreme Court’s orders.
“By
defying the Supreme Court’s recent principled ruling, the Nepal
government is violating its obligations under national and international
law to provide justice and accountability,” said Sam Zarifi, Asia
director at the International Commission of Jurists. “All eyes are now
on the Supreme Court to see whether it will allow the Nepal government
to legislate impunity for perpetrators of crimes under international
law, such as unlawful killings, enforced disappearances, and torture,
including rape and other sexual violence.”
The
international community should support and encourage initiatives that
can deliver real justice for victims of human rights violations in Nepal
and oppose those that could shield perpetrators from accountability,
Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and the International
Commission of Jurists said.
Last year, EU missions,
including Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, UK, and the EU delegation,
joined by Norway and Switzerland, issued a statement calling for
credible and independent commissions that do not have the authority to
confer amnesty for serious human rights abuses and that have regard for
victims’ needs. The donors said they would “be unable to support
mechanisms that do not meet international standards.” Nepal’s donors
need to live up to their promise and refrain from supporting government
processes that violate Nepal’s international legal obligations.
“There
is no question that the TRC, if implemented without serious amendments,
will entrench a culture of impunity rather than delivering justice,”
said Brad Adams, Asia director at Human Rights Watch. “Donors need to
unequivocally refuse to participate in any process that strips victims
of their rights.”
http://www.amnesty.org/en/for-media/press-releases/nepal-fix-flawed-truth-reconciliation-act-2014-07-09